Best Ice Cream Makers of 2024

Overview

When you make your own ice cream, you have full control over the ingredients and flavorings, often resulting in a more delectable product than store-bought. With an ice cream maker, you can make any ice cream type you desire from the comfort of your home, but selecting the right model can be a daunting task.

We collected some of the most popular ice cream makers, including electric, fully automatic, and soft-serve options. Our evaluation criteria included ease of use, design, ice cream texture, mix-in distribution, ease of cleaning, and overall value. Our aim was to identify and present only the finest models available.

What to consider before buying best ice cream makers?

Size

Although not a necessity in most households, ice cream makers can be enjoyable to experiment with, and many people appreciate cold, extra-smooth ice cream year-round. If you have space to store one, an ice cream maker can be a valuable addition to your kitchen.

Ice cream makers come in various sizes, from small, single-serve models that take up minimal counter space to larger compressor models that are difficult to move around. Some are also designed for freezer use and don't require electricity.

Settings & Options

Ice cream machines range in features from basic on/off switches to advanced features such as timers, automatic shut-off, keep cool functions, special paddles, and more. The compressor-style ice cream makers usually have more controls and options for making different styles of ice cream compared to other models. While having options and versatile appliances is excellent, sometimes a simple model that performs its primary function efficiently is all that is necessary.

Ability to make multiple batches

The type of ice cream maker you choose will determine whether you can make multiple batches in a row. Freezer bowl models can only make one batch of ice cream before the bowl needs to be frozen again, but having an extra freezer bowl can make it easier to make multiple batches back to back.

Compressor models and salt-and-ice models can produce a second or third batch more easily. However, churning hard ice cream can stress and overheat the motor of less robust models, so if you plan to make many batches of ice cream for large parties, a low-end commercial model may be a better investment than one made for lighter-duty home use.

Conclusion

Best ice cream maker for you will depend on your specific needs and preferences. Factors such as the amount of ice cream you want to make, the level of control you want over the process, and the frequency of use will all play a role in determining which model is right for you.

By considering these factors, as well as the features and performance of various models, you can choose an ice cream maker that will allow you to create delicious, homemade ice cream right in the comfort of your own home.